New York, NY vs Detroit, MI
Side-by-side fiscal comparison · U.S. Census Bureau data (2023)
Summary
New York spends 315.3% more per capita than Detroit ($98,032/person difference). Detroit, MI has the stronger Fiscal Health Score (B, 69/100).
Fiscal Health Score
C
64/100
Budget Balance55
Debt Burden100
Pension Funding76
Spending Efficiency0
Revenue Diversity100
Trend Direction50
B
69/100
Budget Balance70
Debt Burden79
Pension Funding76
Spending Efficiency38
Revenue Diversity100
Trend Direction50
Key Metrics
Metric
New York
Detroit
Total Spending
$1113.3B
$19.8B
Spending / Capita
$129,119
$31,087
Total Revenue
$1271.6B
$28.4B
Revenue / Capita
$147,477
$44,533
Total Debt
$4.0B
$493.9M
Debt / Capita
$462
$776
Population
8,622,467
636,787
Gov Employees / 10K
0.0
0.0
Avg Gov Salary
$0
$0
Per Capita Spending by Department
Police
New York$1,512
Detroit$0
Fire Protection
New York$11,050
Detroit$2,429
Highways & Roads
New York$221
Detroit$0
Parks & Recreation
New York$868
Detroit$950
Education
New York$37,892
Detroit$0
Health
New York$417
Detroit$396
Revenue Breakdown (Per Capita)
New YorkDetroit
| Property Tax | $5 | $44 |
| Sales Tax | $399 | $200 |
| Income Tax | $19 | $1,045 |
| Intergovernmental | $20,520 | $291 |
| Charges & Fees | $1,835 | $2,228 |
| Other | $3,593 | $6,892 |
Spending Breakdown (Per Capita)
New YorkDetroit
| Police | $1,512 | $0 |
| Fire Protection | $11,050 | $2,429 |
| Highways & Roads | $221 | $0 |
| Education | $37,892 | $0 |
| Public Welfare | $1,116 | $833 |
| Health | $417 | $396 |
| Hospitals | $6,467 | $2,217 |
| Parks & Recreation | $868 | $950 |
| Housing | $7,137 | $5,791 |
| Sewerage | $315 | $451 |
| Utilities | $13,371 | $2,737 |
| Interest on Debt | $11,706 | $2,068 |
| General Admin | $11,668 | $0 |
| Other | $25,380 | $13,216 |
C
New York, NY
Fiscal Health Score: 64/100
Average fiscal health
B
Detroit, MI
Fiscal Health Score: 69/100
Good fiscal health